Goalposts

Hacker News has set AI a lot of challenges over the years. Which ones has it met?

2024 FebruaryThePhysicist

About how people with mainly digital creative skills should plan for AI replacing them.

Maybe, but so far e.g. AI generated images haven't replaced good graphic illustrators. Once they can produce high-quality, consistent illustrations maybe, but they're not there yet, and I would argue that you still need a "professional" to work with AI-generated content as most folks don't have an eye for good design. Personally I'm already a bit tired of all the AI-generated content, people overuse it a lot in presentations and on websites and it's often slightly interesting to look at but also a bit bland and uncreative in its own overblown way (not sure how to describe this better). I still really like websites with high-quality, hand-drawn illustrations like e.g. fly.io or the early versions of the Dropbox website. So I would assume that illustrators will still exist but they will use AI tools to speed up their own workflows, much as we use digital tools today to speed up our work.

AI image generators produce high-quality, consistent illustrations good enough to replace good graphic illustrators.

Has this happened?

Yes 56 (48%)Not sure 28 (24%)No 33 (28%)

Votes cast 1–2 October 2026: 100,590 votes from 9,694 people.