Goalposts

Hacker News has set AI a lot of challenges over the years. Which ones has it met?

2025 Novemberdripdry45

About Claude calling something "weird" in a CSS chat without explaining why.

sorry to reply again, but it also sounds as if the lack of context is causing a problem. The word weird terms on a certain emotion and tone of voice. If this were in person, the other party might have a tone and demeanor that shows that word "weird" indicates a trailing off, a need for pause and contemplation, not a potential pejorative.

questioning someone in an academic matter further, just revert to the academic literature around psychology and therapy, where someone reflects in a literal way upon what they said. The LLM could easily have responded that it was just a trailing stray comment meant to indicate inquisitiveness rather than deflection.

if this were real intelligence, it might take a moment to automatically reflect on why it used the word “weird“ and then let the user know that this might be a point of interest to look into?

An AI reflects on its own word choice without being asked, like why it called something "weird", and points it out to the user.

Has this happened?

Yes 37 (29%)Not sure 49 (39%)No 40 (32%)

Votes cast 1–2 October 2026: 100,590 votes from 9,694 people.